Joan riviere excerpts from womanliness as masquerade. Ebook or pdf edited book email encyclopedia article govt. All her life a certain degree of anxiety, sometimes very severe, was experienced after every public performance, such as speaking to an audience. Apr 17, 2012 i was very pleased at the synthesis of so many theories within rivieres essay womanliness as a masquerade. Every direction in which psychoanalytic research has pointed seems in its turn to have attracted the interest of ernest jones, and now that of recent years investigation has slowly spread to the development of the sexual life of women, we find as a matter of course one by him among the. My suggestion is not, however, that there is any such difference. Why women wear masks a response to rivieres womanliness as. If you are walzeer seller for this product, would you like to suggest updates through seller. Tracing luce irigarays theory in angela carters nights at the circus abstract. Womanliness as masquerade, international journal of. My article, which begins by noting the fluke meeting between writer james joyce and film star marlene dietrich in a paris restaurant, considers the importance of masquerade and gender performativity in three texts of the late 1920s.
Background riviere through psychoanalysis that all people were born bisexual early on in child development certain experiences determine homo or heterosexuality this was written in 1929 consider the time period and certain cultural beliefs. Rivieres place in any feminist history of intellectual thought would be undisputed, but her work. The everyday mask one capable housewife of my acquaintance is a woman of great ability, and can herself attend to typically masculine manners. Female sexuality, feminine identification and the masquerade. Athol hughes courtesy of the melanie klein trust key publications. This conclusion ties beautifully into the observations of riviere in her article womanliness as masquerade.
Gender and the masquerade in james joyce, joan riviere and marlene dietrich, 192530 buy article. Her position in the british psychoanalytic society was unusual as a direct link between freud and klein. Joan riviere, womanliness as masquerade by helen snaith on. The correspondence between freud and jones concerning riviere and her analysis with freud in 1922 also throws light on her experiences and on her personality that are similar to those of the patient she describes in womanliness as a masquerade. Your recently viewed items and featured recommendations.
According to the theory of masquerade, women submit to the social codes by wearing a mask of womanliness while at the same time surreptitiously following their own phallic desires. Doane briefly touches upon the the reversal of the voyeuristic gaze by rendering a male maquerade as an object. Abstract although she published her paper womanliness as a masquerade in 1929, joan riviere wrote it in 1928, the year that women in england got the vote. Joan rivieres womanliness as masquerade and judith butler. Womanliness as a masquerade female sexuality taylor. A response paper to rivieres womanliness as a masquerade written for a gender and media course in the communications department at concordia university, i use my experiences as a stand up comedian to engage with the ideas put forward by. Melanie klein, who she worked with him on child psychology, was the other. Virginia woolf, chapters 2, 5, and 6 from a room of ones own 192935. Using the reallife case of one of her patients as a model, riviere defines the masquerade as a woman s defence against exposing her appropriation of traditionally masculine traits. This chapter explores rivieres womanliness as a masquerade 1929, an essay that enjoys a unique, if uneasy, status in the dialogue between psychoanalysis and feminism.
Why women wear masks a response to rivieres womanliness as a masquerade by sarah stupar coms 368 professor dayna mcleod october 8th 2014 in. Background riviere through psychoanalysis that all people were born bisexual early on in child development certain. The father intense rivalry for his masculine position desire to castrate. Womanliness as masquerade, international journal of psychoanalysis, vol. Becoming a prayer warrior by elizabeth alves pdf drive these feelings have been so raw, that i have had great difficulty forgiving the ones that did this. Published in 1977 with a great deal of controversy within european feminist circles, luce irigarays this sex which is not one presents the authors commentary on the modern phallocentric culture, commodification of women and their counteraction disguised within the very. Woman, on the other hand, are taught the same masculine form of language as man, and therefor cannot possibly identify femininity as a separate entity. Dec 06, 2017 womanliness as masquerade was published in 1929 in the international journal of psychoanalysis by joan riviere, one of the very few women in freuds early circle. Jun 29, 2019 becoming a prayer warrior by elizabeth alves pdf drive these feelings have been so raw, that i have had great difficulty forgiving the ones that did this. Womanliness as a masquerade gender studies bibliographies in harvard style. Joan riviere, womanliness as a masquerade, the international journal of psychoanalysis, vol. Nov 14, 2018 riviere was also a close friend and colleague of melanie klein and wrote her own highly original and influential papers on female sexuality and other topics, in particular womanliness as a masquerade 1929. In 1929 she published womanliness as a masquerade in which she looks at an area of sexual development of intellectual women in particular, where femininity is a defensive mask that is put on to hide masculinity. Joan riviere s womanliness as a masquerade, published in 1929, is one of the most frequently referred to papers in this collection.
Womanliness as masquerade was published in 1929 in the international journal of psychoanalysis by joan riviere, one of the very few women in freuds early circle. Stella browne, studies in feminine inversion 192333. Mary mcleod bethune southern negro women and race cooperation 1922. Published march 29th by chosen books first published november 1st she covers each of the weapons of warfare, including praying in the spirit and fasting. As well as translating freuds work, riviere published several seminal works of her own.
To be a woman is to disguise fundamental masculinity, and femininity is that disguise. The reader may now ask how i define womanliness or where i draw the line between genuine womanliness and the masquerade. Gender and the masquerade in james joyce, joan riviere and. Riviere had been in analysis with ernest jones, then later with freud himself in vienna, and in the 1920s she became associated with melanie klein and her work. Joan riviere excerpts from womanliness as masquerade 1929. Every direction in which psychoanalytic research has pointed seems in its turn to have attracted the interest of ernest jones, and now that of recent years investigation has slowly spread to the development of the sexual life of women, we find as a matter of course one by. Published in 1977 with a great deal of controversy within european feminist circles, luce irigarays this sex which is not one presents the authors commentary on the modern phallocentric culture, commodification of women and their counteraction disguised. Joan riviere anxiety about exhibiting masculine traits key concepts sexuality and gender roles. The title of the paper takes its cue from the dreams that an analysand, whose history is summed up here, had of people putting on masks in order to avert disaster and injury. Womanliness as a masquerade gender studies bibliographies.
This was a really difficult book to read when i was an undergraduate. Joan riviere and the masquerade psychoanalysis and history. After critically assessing the term masquerade and rivieres reflections on it, i discuss the significance of dietrichs. A contribution to the analysis of the negative therapeutic reaction. Why women wear masks a response to rivieres womanliness. These are the sources and citations used to research womanliness as a masquerade. Womanliness as a masquerade by francesca dill on prezi. Femininity in joan riviere and nella larsen european academic research vol. Joan riviere, womanliness as masquerade by helen snaith. However, in the theory of masquerade, which joan riviere proposed in a 1929 seminal essay, this idea was deconstructed. See for athol hughes editors introduction to this paper. In spite of her unquestionable success and ability. Apr 04, 2019 admin april 4, 2019 april 4, 2019 no comments on bcx53 datasheet pdf.
A response paper to riviere s womanliness as a masquerade written for a gender and media course in the communications department at concordia university, i use my experiences as a stand up comedian to engage with the ideas put forward by. The feminist ideology of the masquerade and the freudian discourse of fetishism could hardly be more antithetical on first consideration. Pdf this paper addresses the topic of anxiety within the context of several key arguments in alenka zupancics what is sex. Joan rivieres theory of femininity as a masquerade what riviere calls masquerade is, to put it simply, a person who is mainly heterosexual yet who plainly displays strong features of the other sex 1929, p. She argues that joan rivieres 1927 case study in her paper womanliness as masquerade and mayotte capecias autobiographical novel je suis martiniquaise, which frantz fanon 1952 draws on.
Riviere was also a close friend and colleague of melanie klein and wrote her own highly original and influential papers on female sexuality and other topics, in particular womanliness as a masquerade 1929. The concept of contemplating the female performance echoed our conversations about butler. Joan riviere died in london in 1962, survived by her only daughter, diana. Riviere explains that her goal in her paper is to show that women who wish for masculinity may put on a mask of womanliness to avert anxiety and the retribution. Every direction in which psychoanalytic research has pointed seems in its turn to have.
This bibliography was generated on cite this for me on tuesday, november 10, 2015. She brought in the feminist freudianism of horney in a way that was fresh and accessible. Joan riviere excerpts from womanliness as masquerade 19291. Joan hodgson riviere 28 june 20 may was a british psychoanalyst, who was in she published womanliness as a masquerade in which she looks at an area of sexual development of intellectual women in particular. Joan rivieres womanliness as masquerade and judith. See for athol hughes editors introduction to this paper available at. Formations of fantasy republishes and interrogates two classic psychoanalytic essays which demonstrate the pivotal role of fantasy in the constitution of sexual identityjean laplanche and jeanbertrand pontalis fantasy and the origins of sexuality with a new afterword by the authors and joan rivieres womanliness as a masquerade. Riviere, womanliness as masquerade 2 of a propagandist nature, which consisted principally in speaking and writing. The former, as constituted by luce irigaray, michele montrelay, mary ann doane, and judith butler, in response to joan rivieres pivotal essay womanliness as a masquerade 1929. Womanliness as a masquerade riviere 1929 focuses on a specific type of women that she refers as intellectual 303. Dec 14, 20 but rivieres argument lies at a deeper core. Formations of fantasy republishes and interrogates two classic psychoanalytic essays which demonstrate the pivotal role of fantasy in the constitution of sexual identityjean laplanche and jeanbertrand pontalis fantasy and the origins of sexuality with a new afterword by the authors and joan riviere s womanliness as a masquerade. Joan riviere womanliness as a masquerade every direction in which psychoanalytic research has pointed seems in its turn to have attracted the interest of ernest jones, and now that of recent years investigation has slowly spread to the development of the sexual life of women, we find as a matter of course one by him among the most important contributions to the subject. Marion bower examines rivieres important legacy and contribution to the early development of psychoanalysis.
927 569 1547 318 184 672 1273 1 60 578 530 1600 144 76 1607 431 242 1330 775 724 1598 1010 1025 491 140 277 39 608 1539 263 1103 559 257 967 632 1536 158 866 566 1065 1429 274 1470 717 859 133 869